Chelsea Piers in 1912 New York City
By Jim Potter
New Chelsea Piers, New York City (1900-1920) fixp

While researching the New York City waterfront and its piers, I found this incredibly detailed photograph of Chelsea Piers. The photograph was identified as having been taken between 1910 and 1920, but I was pretty sure I could narrow the date down to the exact year. In this essay I’ll share some history and explain how I determined the photo was taken in 1912.
The accompanying photograph shows the wide, well paved 11th Avenue looking south from 23rd Street, east of the Hudson River. The massive pink granite bulkhead buildings created a continuous 2,500-foot facade along the waterfront. At each of the docks, the pier sheds were designed to handle the enormous flow of luxury liner passengers of that era, such as the 704-foot RMS Oceanic and 882.5-foot RMS Titanic, though the later ship never made it to New York on its maiden voyage in April 1912. The upper level of the pier sheds held lavish waiting rooms, ticket offices, customs halls, baggage rooms, and telegraph offices. On the lower level were areas to handle freight and storage for ship supplies.

The streets are busy with horse drawn wagons hauling cargo and people to and from the piers, but I’m surprised at not seeing any motor cars. It’s also clear that the streetcars are not trolleys because at the time the city banned overhead wires for aesthetic and safety reasons. Instead of drawing power from above, the trolleys pulled electricity from a third rail hidden in a trench below the street.
In 1912, New York City had over 100,000 horses versus 38,000 cars. It might be unpleasant, but try and imagine how much horse manure accumulated in the city when each horse produced about twenty-two pounds a day—and a quart of urine. During rain, the streets turned into “manure rivers” and in dry weather the waste became toxic dust. Due to the horses, the city faced a massive public health nightmare. The piles of waste bred billions of flies, spreading diseases like typhoid and cholera. Plus, there were thousands of horses that died from exhaustion, their bodies left on the street to rot before removal.
With this ongoing environmental disaster, motor cars saved the day. That’s right, the internal combustion engine, run on gasoline, eliminated the tons of manure and carcasses clogging New York City streets. Motor cars were the savior of the horse manure crisis as they quickly displaced horse-drawn carriages, leading to cleaner, though noisier city streets.

While early electric cars were quieter and cleaner than Henry Ford’s Model T, by 1912 his gasoline-powered vehicle was affordable for the middle class at $590 for the Runabout (two-seat version) or $690 for the Touring car (five-seat version). At the same time, Detroit Electrics, luxury cars, were purchased by the wealthy. The Model 36 Victoria (four-passenger design) cost $2,300; the Brougham Detroit Duplex Drive (designed for five passengers and allowed steering from the front or rear seat!) cost $3,000.
Eleventh Avenue was widely known as “Death Avenue.” It got its nickname because the New York Central Railroad ran freight trains down the middle of the street at ground level, leading to hundreds of fatal accidents with pedestrians and horse-drawn carriages. To lessen the risk of accidents, the city required the railroad to hire men on horseback, known as “West Side Cowboys,” to ride ahead of the trains, carrying a red flag during the day and a red lantern at night.
The closest pier shed or terminal building in the photograph is Pier 62. The sign on the wall announces ocean liner companies White Star, Red Star, and American Lines. They were part of the International Mercantile Marine (IMM), a shipping trust formed by J. P. Morgan to monopolize the North Atlantic Trade. However, the IMM struggled financially because it failed to acquire its biggest rival, Cunard.
I found the buildings and billboards in the photo both fascinating and informative. The Hopkins Manufacturing Company, 548 West 22nd Street, in Manhattan, was known for manufacturing high-quality carriages, delivery wagons, and early automobile bodies.

On the northeast corner of 11th Avenue and 23rd Street, the Terminal Hotel, Cafe & Restaurant catered to travelers using the Erie Railroad Ferry and the Chelsea Piers which were across the street. The photograph’s advertisement credits John Hollings as the proprietor, but that’s inaccurate for the year 1912. While John Holling (the more common spelling) built the hotel and pub in 1860, with a seventy-foot polished bar and etched glass ceiling panels, he sold the hotel to Herman Van Twistern around 1890. Van Twistern kept the name of the bar, John Holling’s Pub. By 1912 Van Twistern had encountered increased pressure to conform to Sunday liquor laws. Since hotels were permitted to serve alcohol on Sundays to guests who were eating a meal, saloons added cheap beds and served a single, rubbery sandwich (that was untouched and never eaten) with every drink to meet the meal requirement. Van Twistern also got into trouble during New York City’s crackdown on businesses operating “disorderly houses” where rooms were rented multiple times a night for prostitution. The Terminal Hotel and its saloon remained open despite repeated raids because it paid “protection money” to the New York City Police Department.
A block away from the Terminal Hotel, on the corner of 11th Avenue and West 22nd, at 162 11th Avenue, another hotel and bar were targeted for vice crackdowns involving liquor law violations and prostitution. It was called the O’Rourke Brothers Hotel and was known for heavy drinking and frequent brawls.
The photograph shows a billboard advertising Old Quaker rye whiskey. It was a prominent brand produced by the Corning Distilling Company in Peoria, Illinois. Before prohibition, the whiskey was marketed as a high-quality, pure medicinal and recreational spirit. It seems odd to advertise whiskey with a connection to Quakers, but the idea was to imply that the spirit was pure and honest. The Quakers, members of the Religious Society of Friends, objected.

There are a few buildings in the Chelsea Piers neighborhood involving steel construction and electrical repair. Most likely, these businesses helped build and service the docks and their pier sheds.
One billboard advertises Nebo cigarettes. They were first produced in 1903 by the P. Lorillard Company. The billboards to the left of Nebo cigarettes were extremely helpful to me in determining the year of the photograph because they were advertising contemporary Broadway shows.
The billboard advertising the theater production of the comedy Scrape ‘O the Pen, by Scottish playwright Graham Moffat, opened at the Weber’s Theater on September 26, 1912, and closed on December 1st. The theater was located at Broadway and 29th Street, in the heart of the theater district of that era.


I discovered a tragic nugget by researching the billboard advertising The Talker, a 1912 Henry B. Harris theater production that began its run on January 8, 1912, and closed in June the same year. Harris, a prominent Broadway producer of over thirty shows, died April 15 during the sinking of the HMS Titanic. Henry insisted his wife, Rene (“Reenie”), take a spot in a lifeboat while he remained on the sinking ship. Despite Henry’s death, the production of The Talker continued its successful run at the Harris Theater. Rene, who was an active partner of the business, took over and successfully managed the Harris and Hudson theaters for two decades.
Since Scrap ‘O the Pen opened September 26, 1912, and closed on December 1st, I’m convinced the photograph was taken in 1912.
*



Whew! What a vivid depiction of that time!
Thanks!
Fascinating post and great research, Jim! As a native of St. Louis, I wanted to mention that the beautiful Lemp family mansion still exists. It’s considered by some to be haunted because several members of the Lemp family committed suicide there. (Depression seemed to run in the family.) the house has a restaurant and is also available for overnight rental for those with strong nerves hoping to explore the ghost aspect. I’ve had meals there but never stayed overnight!
Shayne, thanks for the promo! I was born in a suburb of St. Louis but our family moved before I was old enough to have an interest in history. I had read about the family’s bad luck and suicides before this blog post, and I do recall Falstaff beer. Good to hear from you again. What’s your latest project? Sincerely, Jim
Fascinating story backed by in-depth research! I especially enjoyed hearing your audio version.
Hello Charlotte, thanks for the response! Sometimes the rabbit holes are very informative and fun. Happy editing! Jim